Red Dead Redemption 2 straight-up drops you into this wild, breathing Old West where every corner can turn into a shootout, you’re constantly riding across huge maps, and harsh survival situations hit hard if you’re not careful. The magic happens when you finally pick the right gun — suddenly you’re the one running the fight instead of the fight running you.
Each RDR2 gun has stats for damage, range, fire rate, accuracy, reload, and more, which I’ve personally tested through many full games. In the following guide, you'll find out what the top 10 RDR2 weapons are, according to how they feel in real gameplay.
Side note: Lootbar offers Red Dead Redemption 2 and other Steam games at significantly lower prices than other platforms.
Up to 12% off on LootBar Game Key.
Instant Delivery for Non-Stop Gaming.
Trusted 4.9/5 on Trustpilot, 10/10 among Players.
Official Partnership Route, Safe and reliable
1. Lancaster Repeater
This lever-action repeater sits at the very top of my list because it handles almost every situation perfectly. I have used it since Chapter 2 until the endgame, and it never let me down. Damage is decent, range is awesome, fire-rate is fast, reloads are quick, accuracy is high, and there is a fourteen-round magazine.
In my experience, it shines during horseback chases, clearing out hideouts, or just riding through the wilderness. I always keep one on my horse because switching to it instantly gives me confidence.
- Pros: Quick shots even while aiming, holds lots of ammo, works great with high-velocity or express rounds, easy to control.
- Cons: Damage is good, but not the absolute highest among rifles.
2. Schofield Revolver
My favorite sidearm by far is the Schofield Revolver. I love how fast and reliable it feels in close fights and duels. The stats show strong accuracy, very quick fire rate, decent range, anda six-round cylinder. It costs about $84 and becomes available right in Chapter 2.
I dual-wield these often, and the speed lets me drop multiple enemies before they can react. The weight and sound feel just right, and it pairs perfectly with any long gun I carry.
- Pros: Lightning-fast shots, accurate even under pressure, looks clean and classic.
- Cons: Damage per shot sits below heavier pistols.
If you want a pistol that feels like an extension of your arm, start with this one early.
3. Bolt-Action Rifle
For delivering real power at medium and long ranges, I depend on the Bolt Action Rifle. I have thoroughly integrated it into the loadout after having earned it through a Chapter 3 mission. This weapon boasts high damage, range, accuracy, and a five-round tube.
One or two shots drop most enemies cleanly, and I use them for clearing enemy camps or taking down big animals from cover. The bolt action feels satisfying, and the reload is faster than I expected for a rifle this strong. I still carry it late in the game because nothing else matches its stopping power in open fights.
- Pros: Hits hard enough to end fights quickly, stays accurate while moving, perfect for defensive positions.
- Cons: Fire rate is slower than repeaters.
I recommend it for anyone who likes to stay back and pick targets carefully.
4. Semi-Auto Shotgun
For messy close-range fights, I always turn to the Semi-Auto Shotgun. It became available after Chapter 4 and costs around $225. The stats give it strong damage, a fast fire rate for a shotgun, and good spread.
I love that I do not have to pump between shots, so I can keep firing while surrounded in caves or buildings. Switching to slug ammo turns it into a powerful medium-range tool too.
- Pros: Rapid shots without pumping, excellent for room clearing, and works well with different ammo types.
- Cons: Range drops off quickly beyond a short distance.
Keep one ready for indoor missions or when enemies rush you.
5. Rolling Block Rifle
The Rolling Block Rifle is my pick for pure long-distance work. I bought it early in Chapter 2 for about $187, and it has the highest damage and accuracy stats among single-shot rifles. One clean shot often finishes the fight before it starts.
I use it for hunting legendary animals or sniping guards from 200 yards away. The scope feels natural, and the power is unmatched. The slow reload is the only downside, but I plan around that, and it pays off every time.
- Pros: Massive one-shot potential, perfect accuracy at distance.
- Cons: Very slow between shots and reloads.
If you enjoy patient, precise shooting, this rifle will become your favorite too.
6. Litchfield Repeater
The Litchfield Repeater brings raw power to chaotic shootouts. I switch to it when I want each shot to count extra. It has high damage and a fast fire rate, though the reload takes a bit longer.
In big gang fights, it feels like a beast because enemies drop faster. I keep it upgraded with the best barrel and grip I can afford. It is not my daily carry, but when things get loud I grab it and enjoy the heavy hits.
- Pros: Strong stopping power up close, fun in aggressive fights.
- Cons: Reload time and slightly less accuracy at long range.
Great choice when you expect to be in the middle of the action.
7. Carbine Repeater
Early in the game, the Carbine Repeater carried me through the first chapters. It costs only $90 and gives balanced stats across damage, range, and accuracy right from the start.
I still pull it out for casual rides or when I want something light and dependable. It upgrades easily and never feels weak. Many of my first successful missions happened because this repeater was reliable when I needed it most.
- Pros: Cheap and available early, all-around solid performance, easy to master.
- Cons: Not the best in any one category.
A smart starting gun that stays useful for a long time.
8. Volcanic Pistol
For maximum damage from a handgun, I choose the Volcanic Pistol. It packs a heavy punch with eight rounds and strong stats for damage and medium range.
- Pros: High damage per shot, reliable at medium distances.
- Cons: Not as quick on follow-up shots.
Perfect sidearm when you need stopping power over speed.
9. Carcano Rifle
The Carcano Rifle stands out for long-range precision later in the story. I unlocked it in Chapter 6 and immediately appreciated its speed and accuracy for a bolt-action rifle.
It combines good damage with fast cycling, making it easier to line up multiple shots than slower snipers. I use it on missions where distance keeps me safe. The performance feels sharp and modern for the time period.
- Pros: Very accurate, quicker reload than expected.
- Cons: Available later than other rifles.
Excellent once you reach that point in the game.
10. LeMat Revolver
For something different, I enjoy the LeMat Revolver. It gives nine pistol rounds plus one shotgun barrel in the same gun. The versatility surprised me in tight corners.
I keep it as a backup when I want options without swapping weapons. The design looks unique, and the extra blast comes in handy more often than I expected.
- Pros: Built-in shotgun option, fun variety in fights.
- Cons: Pistol damage is slightly lower than that of dedicated revolvers.
It adds nice flavor to my loadout without sacrificing too much.
Conclusion
After multiple full playthroughs where every gun was tested, these ten guns cover almost every basis in Red Dead Redemption 2. My core loadout is always Lancaster Repeater and Schofield Revolver because together, they handle ninety percent of situations nicely. If you don’t have the game yet, Lootbar offers Red Dead Redemption 2 Steam key at a discounted price. It’s one of the most reliable platforms.
